Skip to main content

New research reveals being an environmentalist is ‘hypocrisy’

A study on reputation and morality shows the perils of taking a stand and how leaders can lessen the chance of it backfiring.

Save to my profile
Smiling Greta Thunberg wearing a black beanie and scarf, outdoors with blurred colourful lights in background.

In 30 Seconds

  • Whenever someone tries to support green policies, their everyday behaviour is scrutinised.

  • In business, where decisions often involve some sort of trade-off, leaders taking a moral position is a risky endeavour.

  • Four principles help explain when companies are likely to become targets of hypocrisy accusations.

Greta Thunberg didn’t mince her words when she arrived at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey: “It’s a hypocrisy every year that the host countries are given an opportunity to whitewash themselves and we know that these negotiations are filled with lobbyists, paid by the very destructive industries which are benefiting from our extremely violent status quo.

“Our political and economic systems have become incompatible with human nature.”

But Thunberg herself has been accused of hypocrisy. In 2019, when the then 16-year-old sailed across the Atlantic to speak at a UN summit on zero emissions, she was criticised.

Thunberg had pledged to give up air travel to reduce her carbon footprint, but in order for her to travel by sea, four of the crew had to take transatlantic flights.

Her team insisted that they would be offset, yet if Thunberg herself had flown, making the overall carbon footprint lower, she would have faced accusations of hypocrisy.

“It’s very hard to be an environmentalist because almost everything we do as human beings causes some degree of harm,” says Jonathan Berman, Associate Professor of Marketing at LBS. “There are always trade-offs.”

His latest paper, Hypocrisy either way: Judgments of moral actors who choose between conflicting commitments, explores this tension, and how taking a moral stand can be reputationally fraught.

“When Al Gore was campaigning on environmental issues, people criticised him for flying first class,” Berman says.

“You could make a reasonable argument that he needed to travel comfortably to speak around the world and do his job effectively, not be exhausted or suffering from a bad back or neck.

“But people viewed his behaviour suspiciously. They argued that he was promoting environmental responsibility while doing something that appeared to contradict that commitment.”

Straddling the environmental messaging

Berman wanted to explore these sorts of situations, in which people or organisations appear to be saying one thing but doing another.

Discover fresh perspectives and research insights from LBS

“Whenever someone tries to support green policies, their everyday behaviour is scrutinised. People want to know whether they walk the walk as well as talk the talk.”

“It’s important to distinguish between two questions. One: is someone genuinely a hypocrite? And, two: will other people call them a hypocrite? Our research is primarily concerned with the second question,” Berman explains.

Berman and his co-authors (Graham Overton, of NUS Business School in Singapore, and Daniel Effron, Professor of Organisational Behaviour at LBS), make the distinction between higher-order goals and behavioural commitments.

A higher-order goal is the ultimate objective someone is trying to achieve: protecting the environment, improving welfare or promoting some other moral value. Behavioural commitments are the specific actions or behaviours that someone is expected to undertake in support of that goal.

“For example, if you promote environmental protection, people may assume that you should consistently make the most environmentally-friendly choices in your everyday life. That expectation can become a commitment, whether it is explicitly stated or simply assumed by others,” Berman states.

The difficulty arises when circumstances change and a particular behaviour no longer makes sense. “You might change your behaviour because doing so is now more consistent with your overarching goal, but other people may still interpret that change as hypocrisy.”

Meet ‘Brad’, a fictional man who had the goal of reducing his carbon footprint. In a study, nearly 800 participants were told Brad either did or didn’t commit to becoming a vegetarian in pursuit of this goal.

At a lunch, Brad was faced with two options: a lower-carbon chicken curry (violating his behavioural commitment) or a higher-carbon vegetarian coconut curry (violating his goal of reducing carbon emissions).

Whichever he chose, the study participants judged him a hypocrite. And in further studies, the researchers found the same condemnation awaited other hapless individuals who were trying to do the right thing.

Another example was ‘Sam’, who was boycotting the national retail chain Home Depot because he it took jobs away from local hardware stores. But then, Home Depot itself risked closure because of Amazon, so he started shopping there. ‘Hypocrite’, the study found.

How can businesses avoid the ‘hypocrisy either way’ bind

In business, where almost every decision involves some sort of trade-off, leaders often make difficult calls, and something has to give.

Taking a moral position is a risky endeavour, it transpires. “If a company says it is going to do something, consumers continue to expect it to do so,” states Berman. “If the world changes and the original commitment no longer make practical sense, you might still be judged by the everyday consumer for abandoning it.”

The people who criticise environmentalists often have an explicit agenda to undermine their credibility. “Establishing whether someone is genuinely hypocritical requires a holistic understanding of that person and their motivations,” Berman points out.

But sometimes it is simply an emotional reaction, it seems: “People feel that someone is telling them to behave in a particular way without holding themselves to the same standards. That touches on people's sense of fairness.”

“Hypocrisy is an easy accusation to make, even when people can’t fully articulate why someone's behaviour feels wrong to them. Sometimes it just feels off.”

So just how can businesses avoid this hypocrisy bind? Companies need to have a very well-developed articulation of why they are doing whatever it is, says Berman. They should ask themselves the following: What are our underlying values? What moral commitments help serve those values? How far are we willing to go to support those commitments? Where do we draw the line when making difficult decisions?

“Even though our research highlights some tensions, having clarity about your underlying values and the reasons for your actions can help businesses anticipate potential problems, avoid some of the pitfalls and respond more effectively when criticism arises,” says Berman.

“A company needs to understand its own position well enough to anticipate the situations in which it might be criticised.

“Accused of inconsistency, you need to be able to say: ‘This is why we are doing this, these are the values guiding our decisions, and this is how we make judgements about where to draw the line.’ The last thing you want is to be caught off guard and then come up with an off-the-cuff response that doesn't sit well with people.”

In the classroom, Berman and his students discuss examples such as Baker Hughes, a US company that manufactures drill bits for fracking that also ran a breast cancer awareness campaign. Was that genuine corporate social responsibility or hypocrisy?

He has identified four principles that help explain when companies are likely to become targets of accusations of hypocrisy. First, how much is the company actually sacrificing? If a company is simply running a promotional campaign, without putting resources, money or commercial interests behind its commitment, that makes its actions seem less authentic.

Second, is the company a pioneer or a follower? TOMS Shoes’ business model involved donating a pair of shoes to charity for every pair purchased, and the company was seen as genuine. But when Skechers adopted a similar model, people viewed it more negatively.

Being the first to introduce a moral initiative can help establish credibility. Following someone else's example, even if you make an equivalent contribution, may not generate the same response.

Third, is the company a market leader or an underdog? Google, for example, once seen as a relatively small, promising challenger, began attracting greater scrutiny as it became enormously successful and profitable.

“As a company becomes more successful, people may question whether its social and environmental initiatives are genuinely motivated by a desire to do good.”

Finally, does the initiative fit with the company's underlying identity? For example, it can be difficult for luxury brands to support poorer communities via charitable giving, when they represent status and exclusivity.

“That can create a tension,” says Berman. “People may question whether the initiative really fits with the company's underlying values and business model.”

Ultimately, avoiding accusations of hypocrisy comes down to integrity and good communications.

“A company might say: ‘We understand that you care about A, and we share that concern. However, our particular initiative is designed to address B, and that is the principle guiding our decisions. This is how we intend to proceed, and these are the circumstances in which we might need to reassess.’

“That kind of clarity can help people understand why a particular decision makes sense, even if it doesn't appear perfectly consistent with an earlier commitment.”

Jonathan Berman

Jonathan Berman

Associate Professor of Marketing

Kathy Brewis

Kathy Brewis

Sign up to receive our latest news and business thinking direct to your inbox

close